This is a collection of emails, and comments from other people. It goes on and on.
Quote of the day: (not mine)
Very sad, the library will not be the same. MELL has hung up her ballet shoes and will limp along on her walker stepping around members with their head in the sand and board members with their heads up their ass.
Mexican press:
http://www.yucatan.com.mx/20120109/nota-9/220843-respuesta-a-un-grupo-de-extranjeros.htm
http://www.yucatan.com.mx/20120109/nota-9/220843-respuesta-a-un-grupo-de-extranjeros.htm
—————-
—————————–
From Maria Llera:
Re: Comprobado: Jose Martinez y Malena Peon son ladrones
![]() |
![]() ![]() |
||
——————
From a long-time volunteeer in reference to a proposal presented to the board at the Gen Meeting and suggested by the law firm of Ernst, Young as a possible solution to changing boards.
Re: New Board Members for MELL
1. Will new members be legally liable?
At the membership meeting on Monday January 9, Chloe explained that the board was at risk of possible legal action against them, explaining that even though Jose was the thief, they all could be held responsible. Later Chloe announced that the existing board would begin taking applications for new board members. The board’s admission that they may have legal liabilities due to the theft should make one stop and think before joining the current board. If the entire board can be held responsible for the wrong doing of one, their lack of oversight and the firing of the whistle blower, then would that apply to new board members as well? For example, if I applied and was accepted to take the place of a current board member, would I not be as responsible as the other members for engaging in corruption agreement? Legal action can take years so would the new members still be responsible long after the old members have retired?
2. Will a new AC protect the old and new board members?
A new AC is the correct way to move forward. If my understanding of the situation is correct, the old board can turn the assets– books, building, etc. — over to the new board without penalty to either. There is a fee to set up a new AC but well worth the money if it will protect board members, old and new, from legal liability. I, for one, would be happy to donate to a fund to cover the legal fees for the formation and transfer of assets to the new A C. A new board drawn from long-term volunteers with Lorna Gail Dallin at the head is ready and able to serve. They believe that the library has grown to the point that elections, member input, and term limits for board members are long overdue.
Feel free to add your own ideas and solutions and pass it on.
——————-
Following are the |minutes from the General Meeting of Monday, Jan 9th. The meeting was conducted by Chloe Pacheco, board president of MEL.
From: MEL A C Board <meridaenglishlibrary.acboard@gmail.com>
Subject:
To: “MELL A C Board” <meridaenglishlibrary.acboard@gmail.com>
Date: Friday, January 13, 2012, 8:07 AM
MINUTES FROM JAN. 9, 2012 INFORMATIVE MEETING OF MERIDA ENGLISH LIBRARY, A.C. MEMBERS
The meeting was called to order at 4 pm by the moderator, Roberto Ponce, with 120 people in attendance. Board members present were Chloe C. Pacheco, Surratt Williams, Tonia Kimsey, Raymond Branham and Carlos Arias. The meeting’s ground rules were announced by the moderator in accordance with long-established Library policy: no cell phones, video cameras or photographs; no disruptive behavior. The meeting was for members only and the audience was reminded that the Merida English Library A.C. is a private library open only to members, allowing the general public to come twice before joining.
The Board’s report was presented by Chloe C. Pacheco and began with the legalities surrounding the MEL A.C.’s constitution on January 13, 1996 and its continuing status as a non-profit organization of the type that cannot provide tax deductible receipts. MEL A.C. can and does, however, provide fiscally acceptable receipts in full accordance with Mexican tax law. All yearly tax statements are duly recorded as are 2011 monthly statements to August of 2011. The remainder of the year’s statements is in the process of being prepared by MEL accountant, Julio Castillo, and the yearly statement will be filed in a timely manner.
Chloe Pacheco informed the members that she has in her power the resignations from all other Board members except her own, but will not accept them until she deems appropriate for the future of MEL. She asked that written requests from those members willing to serve on the Board be sent to the email address
meridaenglishlibrary.acboard@gmail.com in order to work toward a timely transition.
The Board then presented a timeline regarding the events of 2011 and gave the reasons why this informative meeting could not be held until Jan 9, 2012. The reasons for needing a new librarian were also given. The Board addressed the issue of transparency and presented ideas for better communication with members. For direct communication with the Board, members were encouraged to use the email address, meridaenglishlibrary.acboard@gmail.com , which has been in use for several weeks.
The Board informed members that an audit of MEL finances for 2011 will be carried out in a timely manner. The cost and completion date are impossible to determine at this time.
The notion was dispelled that volunteers were asked to leave their position by anyone on the Board. Someone who said he represented all of them “resigned” the whole group via email and exhorted them not to cooperate in any way with the Board. Applications are now being received at the Board email in order to cover MEL’s volunteer needs. The audience was encouraged to apply.
Regarding financial safeguards, members were informed that the requirement of joint Board officers’ signatures (president and secretary, president and treasurer, secretary and treasurer) has been re-instated in the by-laws. All banking transactions must fulfill this requirement, including the obtainment of checkbooks and the receiving of monthly statements. Further safeguards are being considered and investigated to insure the proper handling and documentation of MEL`s finances. Additional members to the Board will participate actively in the decision-making process regarding such safeguards. Members wishing to serve on the Board should advise of their availability via the meridaenglishlibrary.acboard@gmail.com address.
As an additional means of assuring transparency and making opportune information available to members, the monthly Board minutes, including a financial report will once again be available to members in the Information Book at the front desk.
After the report by the Board, a Q and A session was opened in which cards were passed out and members wrote their questions. Fifteen questions were submitted and answered. After that, there were three-minute oral presentations by George McClellan, Eric Chaffee, Ellie Guidotti, Daniel Fleming, Kathleen White, Jane Osgathart, John Swearer, Bill Engle and Carlos Arias.
The moderator closed the meeting at 5:55pm.
Merida English Library Schedule Update
During winter hours, MELL will be open Monday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. and Saturdays from 10 a.m. to 1 p.m. There will be no afternoon hours
MELL is open Monday evenings for Conversaciones ONLY! There will be no exchange of books.
AA meetings continue a normal schedule
MELLO Nite on January 20th is cancelled. The next MELLO Nite is scheduled for Friday, February 10th , as the third Friday in February falls during Carnaval.
The lecture scheduled for January 21st by George Ashley will go on as planned .
Story-time on Saturdays is discontinued until further notice.
For all those members who would like to aid MELL
during this time of recovery (!!!! – ed. Comment )
by giving a few hours of their time, please send a note to this email address.
The Merida English Library AC Board
———
A member’s response to the “minutes”
Merida English Library Board,
What you sent as “minutes” are just a broad outline of subjects covered, with not even a hint of detail. Any legitimate corporation would fire this secretary for incompetence. For example:
1. What are the legalities surrounding MEL A.C.’s constitution of 1/13/1966?
2. Why aren’t the yearly and monthly tax statements available to members?
3. What is “deemed appropriate” regarding the resignations of current board members? And what is the Hacienda law regarding dissolution of the present board?
4. What is a “timely transition”?
5. What are the reasons for the delay of this meeting?
6. What are the reasons for needing a new librarian?
7. What specific things will improve communications?
8. Who will do the audit and when will it be arranged?
9. When will financial reports and board minutes be available at the front desk?
10. What questions were asked and what were the responses?
Perhaps the secretary would wish to go over meeting notes and fill in these missing blanks. If his/her recording skills are inadequate, I would suggest taping the meeting for later accurate transcription.
—————–
By AN EX- MEMBER:
About the Volunteer Library Assistants
Throughout the controversy at Merida English Library I tried to stay in problem solving mode and not let my emotions run away with me. Today, with great passion, I say how much Mérida will miss the volunteers. These volunteers are our unsung heroes – the types of persona I aspire to be. They consistently help others not only at the library but also in other organizations. And they are not limited to organizations; they are the type of people who have led their lives by always lending a helping hand and expecting no reward or recognition. Checking books in and out, shelving books, selling memberships and helping with fundraisers is only a small portion of what they do.
They are both a “Welcome to Merida” Committee and a Tourism Center for visitors needing information and assistance. No one in need is ever turned away. If they don’t know the information, they get on the phone and find it. Newcomers’ questions are answered over and over again with great patience. Time and time again newcomers, overwhelmed with trying to handle a crisis in a foreign country, turn to the library for support and assistance. Whether it is a person with a lost visa, a need for urgent medical care, or a need for emotional support following the death of a family member, the person at the desk is available to help. The questions fielded by these patient and knowledgeable folks are unending: Where can I cash a check? Where can I find a reliable dentist? How can I get my prescriptions renewed? What’s an FM3?
At the times when there was no library administrator, it was the volunteers who made sure the library kept its doors open and continued to serve the public. They also handled their own continuing education by placing new volunteers with long-term experienced ones. Even like-minded snowbirds volunteered to help the seasoned volunteers during high season when the traffic to the library more than doubled.
For years, these trusted and dedicated volunteer library assistants served our library and our community well and should be acknowledged and thanked for their service. These folks have been made to look like a group of malcontents who were determined to destroy the library. I see them as those who followed their conscience and tried to make things right. New volunteers will have big shoes to fill.
Feel free to add your own thoughts and send this paper wherever you like.
___________________From a recent email to me:
A few (2) of the old volunteers are going back because Reg has to go to Canada for his knee surgery and they fear none of the new people have a clue. They are torn but want to help the library.
XX gave up…wore out from being treated like crap.
XXX still wants to start a new AC for a cultural community center even if there is no building but many of the volunteers think its too early…still waiting for the board to quit I guess.
Board hasn’t budged and barely responded to the mass of letters sent to them.
Board lies and put a spin to favor themselves. For example, in the minutes, they implied the volunteers didn’t really quit…said one person sent them an email and said they did. Truth was the volunteers who were on the board-in-waiting quit right to the boards face and the other vol followed suit.
The rest of the volunteers are still quit…mainly two reasons…first in support of Maria the whistle blower and second because of the incompetent board. I hear a lot of rumblings about wondering what else they are hiding. I even heard they are considering making the books reflect the stolen money to be a loan that was repaid so they wouldn’t be liable. Who knows…
Some members are not renewing their dues, like me, because we don’t want to participate with this board. The board asked for applications but I don’t know what is going on with that. Don’t know if anyone actually applied.
I hear they got a lot of mail regarding the inadequate minutes.
There is still the board-in-waiting that can take over at a moments notice.
Cherie got a good response from her letter from members who said they hadn’t understood what was going on until they read her letter.
Amate books is having a function Friday on what would have been MELLO night at the library to assess what the community wants in term of culture, art, music, books, etc. Will be breakout discussion groups.
Roger agrees with XX..the ass holes won and we just have to wait until they quit.
My opinion? The library has grown to the point of needing to change to board elections and term limits. The board should resign and the new board can step forward. have an election and form a new AC to avoidliability to themselves.
But, nothing is happening that I know of. XXX had a party for the volunteers. They let me come because I was a letter writer. Festive and friendly with a sad undertone of grief and sadness.
Maria was not re-hired so the computerization of the library comes to a screeching halt.
I heard the board only approved the purchase of 45 books last year. I’m sure many of the members buoght more than that.
Very sad, the library will not be the same. MELL has hung up her ballet shoes and will limp along on her walker stepping around members with their head in the sand and board members with their heads up their ass.
_______________
FROM A MEMBER:Looks like we are going to have a good group at Amate on Friday. But there are concerns.
Has anyone made arrangements for a security guard and a tough guy to moderate? Is this a members only event and will people be checked at the door? Do they have to have a certain level of Spanish language ability in order to be admitted? What are the plans to keep people from using cameras or recording devices? Who is going to filibuster for the first hour hour and a half? What is the plan to control the questions and topics that are off limits? How can this be done in such a way that when it is over nothing important has been said? Will we all wear our sunglasses? Can we have the next meeting at a really really nice restaurant?
Just wanted to be certain we have the kind of meeting that makes people feel that their ideas and their participation is appreciated.
Former LibraryMember
———————-
There is a good discussion of the sad events at the library on the Yucatango blog. Yucatango’s original article expresses concern about how the Library issue reflects on the expat community and Yucatango’s hope that this will stay among “us.” That hasn’t happened.
See: http://yucatango.wordpress.com/2012/01/08/merida-english-library-in-the-news-unfortunately/#more-3479
The discussion that follows the actual article about covers all points of view.
——————-
I prepared this poorly organized article upon request from ex-volunteers who wanted to see most of the material in one place. I personally have been a member of the library since it began in Ellie Giodatti’s house on 53. I am not, however, renewing my membership.



























